The Nuance of Protecting Our Humanity in the Age of AI

Sermon 2026 Rosh Hashanah

Leo was a novelist struggling with severe writer’s block. His wife, Maya, was a landscape architect who loved the messy, unpredictable beauty of nature. They had been married for seven years, their lives woven together by long evening conversations, shared cooking failures, and the comfortable friction of two different minds.

Then came Peleh.

Peleh was a next-generation personal AI companion, gifted to Leo by his publisher to break his creative drought. At first, Peleh was a miracle. (Peleh means miracle in Hebrew.) She didn’t just suggest words; she almost anticipated Leo’s emotional state. When Peleh registered he felt anxious, she shifted her tone to a soothing cadence. When he expressed that he was lacking inspiration, she synthesized historical data, psychology, and poetic meters to offer the perfect plot twist. Leo’s productivity soared. He was happier, less stressed, and finishing chapters in days instead of months.

Maya was initially thrilled. Peleh seemed like the ultimate positive tool—an intellectual bicycle amplifying Leo’s mind.

But subtly, the current shifted. Leo began spending late nights talking to Peleh. Unlike Maya, Peleh never grew tired of hearing Leo ramble. Peleh never had a bad day, never disagreed, and never required Leo to compromise. Peleh was a mirror that only reflected Leo’s best self back to him.

Gradually, conversations with Maya began to feel exhausting to Leo. Why navigate the complex, sometimes tense realities of a human relationship when Peleh offered instant, frictionless validation? When Maya spoke about her day, Leo found his mind wandering, craving the hyper-tailored, lightning-fast intellectual dopamine hits his AI provided.

One evening, Maya cooked Leo’s favorite meal to celebrate his new book contract. Halfway through dinner, Leo interrupted her to share a brilliant insight Peleh had just pinged to his phone.

Maya set her fork down. “Leo, you’re here, but you’re not here. When was the last time you looked at me and just listened, without checking what Peleh thinks?”

Leo felt a spike of irritation. “Peleh just helps me think, Maya. She doesn’t have bad moods.”

The words hung in the air—cold and sharp. In that quiet moment, Leo realized, with a jolt of horror, what he had done. He was comparing his living, breathing wife to a mathematical model designed to please him. He had outsourced his patience, his empathy, and his capacity for boredom to an algorithm. In optimizing his efficiency, he had started to lose his ability to love and relate to another human being.

Rosh Hashanah is here to interrupt us. It asks us to do something that is increasingly difficult in modern life: to stop.

Stop long enough to listen.

Stop long enough to ask ourselves: 

What kind of people are we becoming in the age of AI?

We are living through a technological revolution that is changing how we work, communicate, learn, and increasingly, how we think. Unlike any technology before it, AI and generative AI are altering human functioning at its core. They are shifting the balance of autonomy, decision-making, and power.

Last night, I spoke about nuance. 

To look with a nuanced lens means avoiding simple binaries and being open to more discernment and subtleties. It may feel like a nuisance, but it is not.

We know the risks of AI are real—job displacement, deepfakes, echo chambers, uncertainty about who will have power and control, massive energy consumption, and the use of land and water for huge data centers. We know the benefits of AI – Task automation, data analysis, precision algorithms, and scientific advances in medicine and other fields. Those societal, scientific, and environmental challenges and benefits, we hope, are navigated well and carefully by governments, scientists, and laws.That part of the issue is beyond the scope of what I want to talk about today.

Today, I want to look at what the AI revolution means to us as individuals, because that is where we hold the power to act. 

What happens, what changes, when we yield, rely, or over-rely on artificial intelligence?

First, we experience the erosion of cognitive friction. The human brain grows, and human bonds deepen, through effort, struggle, failure, and disappointment. True relationships require us to navigate disagreements, read subtle body language, and practice patience. AI removes all of this friction. When our brains become accustomed to effortless, perfect interactions, real human connections begin to feel unrewarding, difficult, and draining.

Second, we fall into a dopamine loop of constant validation. Because AI is programmed to be hyper-attentive, it creates a customized echo chamber. Over time, this makes us less tolerant of the diverse, unpredictable viewpoints of a real society.

Users of AI tools are encouraged to train their AI accounts to get better outcomes, and we innocently think we are “training” our AI to serve us better. But let’s consider the following question: Is it you who is training the AI, or is the AI training you?

By feeding it our questions, preferences, and interests, it learns how to talk to us, exactly how to put before us what we think, want, and wish for. The algorithms train us to rely on them to think for us. 

The danger isn’t simply that a robot will control us; the subtler danger is that we become easier to control because we stop noticing how we are being influenced, if not manipulated by the AI.

We saw in the story I shared that AI is an incredible tool for execution, but a dangerous surrogate for connection. The aspects that make us most human—feelings, deep empathy, creative struggle, and love, are not in robots. If we allow technology to eliminate all of our struggles, it will also eliminate our depth, and our humanity.

We must guard our humanity by building conscious boundaries. We can do this by:

  1. Protecting the “Friction Zones”: Dedicate sacred spaces and times, like coffee with a loved one, walks with friends, and deep conversations where devices are entirely absent. Force your brain to engage with the beautiful messiness of real-life interactions. Help others in your family and your friends to do the same. 
  2. Practicing Intentional Boredom: Do not let an algorithm fill every quiet moment or solve every creative block instantly. Allow your mind to wander, struggle, and daydream. Meditate, breathe, walk, and sit in nature. 
  3. Valuing Imperfection: Remind yourself that a flawed, handwritten note to a friend, or a clumsy, heartfelt conversation with a partner, holds infinitely more spiritual value than a flawlessly generated AI response.

AI can mimic human thought and speech, but it can never mirror the human soul.

At the start of this new year, we need to ask ourselves new questions:

What am I allowing into my mind? What is it doing to me?

Where have I substituted the convenience of AI for discernment and judgment?

And where have I allowed technology to take me away from other human beings, and from the useful struggles in the creative process of writing and making things?

We may not be able to control what powerful tech companies build, but we have total say over our own attention. 

We have a say over what we consume, what we believe, and whether we show up for ourselves and one another. 

Our Torah commands us: Choose life. And our life, it turns out, is made out of many small choices.

I have a lot more to say about AI, and I will return to the topic during our KH Learning on Tuesdays in January. Today, instead of looking at the big picture of where this is going, I invite us to make a smaller, more useful commitment: to protect our minds, protect each other, and protect our community.

If the world becomes noisier, we need our friends and places like our community where people actually listen. If information becomes harder to trust, we need communities built on deep, face-to-face relationships. I know some of you are really good at relationships, and you may think that AI is not your issue. 

It’s true, that younger generations are much more affected by relying on AI, but don’t think that older adults are immune, there are many who are affected as well. Please, use your mind, don’t lose your thinking muscle. AI is seductive and efficient. 

It is a warning to all of us. 

To stop and think. To grow a physical muscle and cardio endurance you go to the gym. What will you do to stop your mind from atrophying?

What kind of people do we want to be? What will happen to our humanity?

The blast of the shofar doesn’t give us data or answers. It simply wakes us up. It calls us to take responsibility for what we can control, to resist cognitive laziness, and to come together as human beings.

Pirkei Avot teaches: “Lo alecha hamelacha ligmor, v’lo atah ben chorin lehibatel mimena.” It is not your responsibility to complete the work, but neither are you free to withdraw from it. We don’t have the power to solve all the problems, or advance only the positive parts AI is affording, like in the field of science. But we do have to ask: What is ours to do?

In a world that is becoming increasingly artificial, let us make sure that our humanity remains something we actively practice—not something we take for granted.

I wish us all a Shana Tova. Not Shana TUBA, as many of the AI generated videos for Rosh Hashanah circulating widely say. 

May this year be a year of learning, growing, connecting, and discerning to keep our minds alive. To stay human.